Rate and write a Review for Gatsby's On The Bay
Reviews to Gatsby's On The Bay
Super nice place, super nice people!
That was a really amazing surprise for us that we found this place by night. Atmosphere is just great!
We will definitely come back soon!
Did you find this review...?
Helpful 0
Not Helpful 0
Atmosphere great. Service wonderful. Salmon soup delicious. Hanger steak served not warm enough. Veggies all much too salty. Wine good. Prices high but would be worth it if food hotter and much less salty. We won't be back.
Did you find this review...?
Helpful 0
Not Helpful 0
I never new this place existed although I drive past it all the time. I had dinner there for my birthday and everything was great (ambiance and food). A little pricey but worth it. I definitely recommend it.
Did you find this review...?
Helpful 0
Not Helpful 0
it is wonderful to have another great bay street restaurant to go to that is close by. and the weekday pre fixe menu is finally here. and what a great concept. $19.20 pre fixe goes with the 1920 theme. we started with and enjoyed the shrimp & sausage in a spicy scampi sauce over toast points and prosciutto& fresh mozzarella risotto cake with a roasted pepper pesto. entrees pork medallions with hot cherry peppers in a port wine sauce and sesame crusted salmon were equally delicious. to top it off the creme brulee was perfectly crunchy & creamy. chez ettore
Did you find this review...?
Helpful 0
Not Helpful 0
Impossibly great food, drinks, and service.
Dinner for 4 was great. The penne was cooked a perfect Al Dente. The crispy salmon was cooked thoroughly and moist. The shirt rib was amazing and melted on the fork. The salad was okay and they don't have an incredible salad selection. Dessert was great as well offering a great selection and perfect portions on dinner and dessert. Service was good but not suffocating. Drinks were good and as long as they do not start using cheap liquor and food this place will be a staple in my dinner rotation.(***note: there is somewhat of a dress code)
Did you find this review...?
Helpful 0
Not Helpful 0
|
|
Similar placesin Staten Island
Open
Subway
Rating: 5.00 Price: $
|
