Log In
Registration
Forgot your password?

Magnolia Bakery

 
Overall Rating 3.8
Total votes: 138
Mark as been there
 
Closed now
Magnolia Bakery will be open in 1 hour 51 minutes

Opening hours

Monday: 07:30 am - 10:00 pm; Tuesday: 07:30 am - 10:00 pm; Wednesday: 07:30 am - 10:00 pm; Thursday: 07:30 am - 10:00 pm; Friday: 07:30 am - 12:00 am; Saturday: 07:30 am - 12:00 am; Sunday: 07:30 am - 10:00 pm;
Time zone: Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) for Magnolia Bakery in New York is -5 hours
 

Place categories and types

Location

Address
200 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023, United States
GPS coordinates
Latitude: 40.775764°
Longitude: -73.9802664°

Contact Information

Phone number
+1 212-724-8101
 

Map of the Magnolia Bakery in New York City

Rate and write a Review for Magnolia Bakery

 
 
 
Add photos

Reviews to Magnolia Bakery

Reviewed December 18, 2015 18:24
Review rating 2
- Poor #21984
Magnolia Bakery? More like Sugar Overdose Central. Cakes here are way too sweet! They're really pretty, which makes them hard to resist, but did I mention the sugar? Wow! Even the like cake is all sweetness. You'd better have a real sweet tooth. As someone who enjoys good butter creams and frosting, I appreciate Magnolia's emphasis on these elements, but they lack richness and taste like confectioner's sugar, rather than granulated.

So, I'd avoid this place, even though it is cute and its cakes attractive, in favor of the many far more grown-up up flavors you can find at nearby establishments.

A quick note on my rating scale: 5 stars = exceptional food & service; 4 stars = excellent food & service; 3 stars = decent to good (top-of-the-line for fast service restaurants); 2 stars = mediocre; 1 star = not recommended.
Did you find this review...?
   Helpful   0
   Not Helpful   0
Reviewed November 29, 2015 04:36
Review rating 4
- Very Good #21985
Late night hours mean you can get your sugar fix up til midnight - which is a good time to beat the crowds. Cupcakes, pies, cookies, cakes, and other goodies abound at this famous New York bakery. I found the chocolate cupcake with chocolate icing/filling incredibly rich and decently moist. In terms of flavors, the PB&J is worth a selection for the perfect execution and novelty alone.
Did you find this review...?
   Helpful   0
   Not Helpful   0
Reviewed November 28, 2015 21:52
Review rating 2
- Poor #21986
I can't speak for the quality of the food, since they don't have vegan options, but I've been here a few times with visiting friends or to pick something up quick for a gift, and have never been impressed. The staff seems to operate in a permanent fog of confusion, and the customers here are a special brand of entitled tourist-- yikes. I'd probably go back if I really wanted to bring someone a baked treat-- I think Magnolia's a pretty solid choice for sweet nibbles-- but I wouldn't enjoy it.
Did you find this review...?
   Helpful   0
   Not Helpful   0
Reviewed November 25, 2015 03:01
Review rating 4
- Very Good #21988
Great cupcakes! Like every other cupcake joint where that is their sole product, it is over priced. Staff are friendly and helpful.
Did you find this review...?
   Helpful   0
   Not Helpful   0
Reviewed July 8, 2015 11:41
Review rating 4
- Very Good #21987
If you like banana pudding then you are going to really enjoy this. Not the stuff you grew up with , but a more grownup version. The pudding was not gloopy, but lighter and rich. Cheesecake to obsess over and the coffee was very good. My only negative comment would be the chocolate truffle cake was a bit dry. I would definitely go back!
Did you find this review...?
   Helpful   0
   Not Helpful   0
 
Similar placesin New York
List places nearby that look like Magnolia Bakery
Closed
1
Wireless Solutions
Rating: 3.60
Closed
2
Photo by Nexus 5 | Nexus 4 Repair Store for Nexus 5 | Nexus 4 Repair Store
Nexus 5 | Nexus 4 Repair Store
Rating: 3.00
Closed
5
Intermix
Rating: 4.00
Closed
6
kate spade new york
Rating: 4.20
Closed
7
Photo by Zac Truelove for El Mitote
El Mitote
Rating: 4.10 Price: $$
Closed
8
Photo by Peter Lau for Papyrus
Papyrus
Rating: 4.00 Price: $$
Closed
9
Photo by Mindy Ramirez for Muffins Cafe
Muffins Cafe
Rating: 4.50 Price: $
Closed
10
Photo by ZAGAT for Amber Upper West
Amber Upper West
Rating: 4.10 Price: $$
Closed
11
Photo by SEE for SEE
SEE
Rating: 4.20
 
Time: 0.12287187576294 SQLA: 102 SQLG: 100