Good Fellows Pizza & Italian

It was okay. Im from nyc so im a little picky when it comes to my pizza. The pepperonis was the size of a penny ..and both the chicken parm and meatball subs was not all that. The bread was soggy and hard .. gave me a stomach ache from the acid from the tomato sauce. They can do better!!!

I REALLY wanted to like this place. I ordered from Edison pizza at a friend's place and was told by an employee that Goodfellows is the same company, but is closer to my area. I LOVED the Buffalo chicken wrap from Edison pizza, but when I ordered the exact same item from Goodfellows, it was terrible. No cheese, no blue cheese dressing. It was nothing but hot sauce and large, unwieldy pieces of chicken. The meal was so acidic that it gave me a stomach ache for the rest of the day and half of the next. I gave it another chance this evening and it was once again terrible. Almost no cheese on my bacon *cheddar* burger, the meat was dry and the fries were rubbery. How do you even get fries to be like that? I know it was a late order, but don't take my order if it's too late to make it properly. I feel bad saying this because the staff is always so kind and pleasant, but I'm hoping that this will be taken as constructive criticism and put towards improvement because I would really love to have the same quality food and menu that Edison Pizza has closer to me.

I am new to New Jersey and this is the place you want to go for authentic tasting pizza. Oh me Oh my...... yummy yummy yummy. And don't get me started on the Gelato! ....:)

Best pizza in the area. Great service. Old school taste. Love this pizzeria!!!

I go there several times per month and I have never been disappointed. Food is absolutely delicious. Something for everybody.
Wonderful staff. Excellent food. Excellent service.

Really not much more you can say.... Outstanding !!!