Rate and write a Review for Bay Street Luncheonette
Reviews to Bay Street Luncheonette
One of our favorite weekend breakfast and lunch places. We have yet to have a bad meal and always enjoy the look and feel of the place. As a native Staten Islander, I am reminded of Paul's Sweetshop in New Dorp and some of the older diners I grew up eating at. Make sure you try an Egg Cream, most people do not even know what they are missing.
Did you find this review...?
Helpful 0
Not Helpful 0
Took 10 people in and found this to be a charming local place. The owner bent over backwards serving us and explaining the history of the diner. If you go, get someone to tell you how the original owner use to post WWII letters in their windows to let the town know how the war was going.
Food, service and atmosphere were all great. Chocolate shake was equivalent to a liquid brownie! highly recommend.
Did you find this review...?
Helpful 0
Not Helpful 0
great addition to downtown staten island. the decor is 1950's with egg creams & soda fountain. the food is great and service wonderful. i have lived and work in stapleton for the past 26 years and it is refreshing to have a great breakfast right in your own neighborhood. support all your local businesses and great restaurants in downtown staten island.
Did you find this review...?
Helpful 0
Not Helpful 0
As soon as you walk in you notice that the decor has a 1950-60's feel. Atmosphere feels like a white only diner. The poorly carbonated sodas are $2.00 a refill which is a rarity for tiny establishments like this one. But the food on the other hand is delicious.
Did you find this review...?
Helpful 0
Not Helpful 0
Cute place but the guy that owns it hovers around and stands over his register counting his money....very annoying.His wife is very sweet and attempts to be accomodating.. decor done very cheaply..tacky.Good music and egg creams but that's about it..
Did you find this review...?
Helpful 0
Not Helpful 0
|
|
Similar placesin Staten Island
Open
Nino's
Rating: 4.40 Price: $$
|
