This review is for the pizza and dine-in experience only. I can't comment (yet) on other items.
We live in the Lyndhurst area and eat pizza every few weeks. The stressful part is always where to order from, as there are about 1000 pizzerias in the area, and they're all average at best.
We went to a meeting at the Wood Ridge library that someone brought pizza to. We were late, it was cold, and my girlfriend and I looked at each other at the first bite and said, "Oh my....this is delicious!" We asked where it was from and were told that it came from right across the street at Wood Ridge Pizza.
So, we had to go back to try it again fresh, and I have to say, it's just delicious! The sauce is amazing, and the crust is light and crisp. It's not at all like most of the pizza we get around here, and we will be back again and again, even if it is a few towns over.
We ate in, and the staff and owner were very friendly. I hope you try it and have the same great experience we did.
I know that this is the first review on Google, and I'm always hesitant to believe the first review because I always feel like it's the owner just trying to make the place look good. Trust me, I have no affiliation with this place, or the owner, and I've NEVER felt compelled to review a place for their pizza before. Enjoy!!