Villaggio Pizzeria

Best pizza in Tuckahoe (Roma's aside). Try the chicken parm rolls or the eggplant-ricotta slice. The guy tossing the pies runs the place. Any owner-operated kitchen is solid in my book.

Their pizza is fairly good. However, at times, it must depend on who is making the pizza because there were times that it wasn't really good. It was dry and overcooked. I also like to order their zeppoles. I used to go there faithfully but stopped doing that since I wanted to buy some dough from them and they charged $8.00 for dough, which I thought was ridiculous. Also, It would have been nice once in a while to be given a free soda since I was a loyal customer.

The best pizza in NY is in Tuckahoe: Villagio.
Tom, the owner is fantastic.
Great for kids. Try Carolina's favorite pizza flavor.

I just ordered a wrap and a hero from Villagio's. The hero was delicious, but the wrap I ordered was disgusting. I ordered the California wrap which is supposed to be chicken cutlet, onions, tomato, avocado, and mozzarella. To my surprise there were bones in the wrap, a sour taste and vinegar odor. I then called to let them know that something was wrong with the wrap, they said that was impossible because it is fresh, I couldn't even get a refund. I am now sick to my stomach and almost cracked a tooth on all of the bones that were in my first bite of the wrap. By the way chicken cutlets should not have bones. I'm sorry to say I will never order from here again.

This is a nice little pizza place about a block away from the train station in Tuckahoe. Not much for atmosphere, but the pizza is pretty good. Their thin-crust margherita is good. They do take out and delivery.