The Landmark Tavern

Great food! We got the corned beef sandwich and the sirloin burger with bacon. Both were delicious! I wouldn't change a thing. The service was good and the decor is nothing special, but really, if the food is fantastic then it doesn't need to be. Definitely recommend!

A bit upscale pub food, like many places it is a sort of Dr. Jekyl&Mr. Hyde - service really tends to fall off when it's busy, but very attentive when it's not. Food is fine for its genre. Nice ambiance from the age and live entertainment at times (check online).

Came in on a Monday to listen to Irish music at 8 pm. Ordered a burger medium rare, was then asked if I was sure I wanted it medium rare....yes... When I receive the burger it was beyond well done. When I mentioned this to the bartender, he said he believe that that was medium rare and I was wrong. Ordered a Guinness it was served way too cold. I get if you're not an Irish bar that you serve Guinness very cold like a lager but if you're an Irish bar you don't have an excuse. I had such a bad experience that it's the only place I didn't leave a tip ever. Bartender needs to change his attitude.

Showed up at 4pm with my fiance, just to try something new. Thought the atmosphere and decor was cozy and the food was decent, but that's about all it had going for it.

After being asked what we'd like to drink we both asked for waters with a lemon, simple enough. Waters came out promptly, lemons came about 15 minutes later when the waitress asked, "you wanted lemons, right?" I also asked for a refill about 10 minutes after we sat down, didn't receive the refill until we were almost finished.

That's strike one.

Now, after we were brought the waters we finally placed our orders. I ordered the shepherds pie and my fiance ordered the fish and chips. Despite the fact that the restaurant was pretty quiet with numerous empty tables, it took at least 30min for our food to finally arrive.

Strike two.

Before we were brought our food, the waitress asked if we would like some bread, to which we both said yes. When did the bread come? Halfway through our dinner. She asked us, "do you still want the bread?" to which I replied, "well, we did ask for bread, so yes". One we finally received the bread, it was cold and stale, like it had been sitting out.

That's strike three.

Never again will we go here. Go to Tir Na Nog instead. Much better experience. The shepherds pie wasn't even that great, at least not "$18 good". On top of all that, not ONCE did our waitress stop by and ask if the food was good or if we needed anything else.

I shouldn't be able to go to Applebee's or Friday's and get better service than I do at a small mid-tier restaurant in Manhattan.

The notes on here about the "night manager" are not first hand. In the 15 years I've known him not once have I seen him exhibit or communicate in an inappropriate (and certainly never in a racist) manner with anyone (much less a customer).

Per his own words "The accusation in the article that I discriminated against Mr. Ohaegbulam because he is black is completely untrue; I happen to be married to a Black woman who is very upset over these accusations. I have never discriminated against anyone because of race,religion or ethnicity."

"Landmark Tavern welcomes all customers no matter what color or what religion or ethnic group they may belong to."