The Garden City Hotel

I went there for day and a half of work training. Lunch and breakfast was provided. Place was nice and had a charm. Food was ok.

Nice hotel with good facilities. The concierge staff are very friendly and helpful. Stayed here numerous times and enjoyed it each time. The summertime patio bar is a great ending to a long day in the office. Close to the local shops and restaurants.

I was here in the summer with my girlfriend just for a local getaway. The room was nice but was overpriced(more than $400) because it was around July 4th holiday. I loved that they had Polo steakhouse by the lobby. Food service was great.. Even though it was ordered very late at night, food was fresh and delicious.
They also had great breakfast setup by the lobby. This place had the best breakfast/lunch ever by far. The concierges at the front desk were very accommodating and showed us which floor was for what.
Anyways, I'd recommend staying here for a night or two if you want to enjoy a nice steak with wine for dinner.

Beautiful venue. Was here for a wedding, it was fantastic. We spent the night, great hotel rooms. This old hotel was renovated nicely, you don't feel the age at all.

Just to UPDATE what I wrote below, I see other people have reported theft at the Garden City Hotel and an indifference from management. This puts my situation in a new light. I think it might be time to switch to the Viana in Old Westbury for future stays.

I hated it this trip and my view has changed due to a theft of my property. Part my fault as I left a $300 item behind. When I got to the airport late in the afternoon, I realized it was left behind. I recalled I left it in the nightstand drawer. I contacted the hotel and informed them promptly. Someone went to the room I was in and nothing. Not an item to be thrown away but obviously, an item to take. So, the person who cleaned my room, who I tipped well, stole my property. Nice. Again, one bad apple story. They have some good people there. The upgrade program they claim to use for returning guests and members is a total joke. There have been no upgrades recently. Unfortunate experience. Manager offer nothing for my unfortunate experience either so that is certainly questionable. If he looked into it, he would find that I am a regular who tips his staff generously and spends thousands at his property on business trips to NY. He needs to go back to hospitality training for sure.