In recommending a good dessert place, my coworkers had me at "homemade ice cream". The reality, as it turned out, proved far better: mega scoops of whimsically named, taste bud-enthralling ultra creamy goodness, for just $4!
This cafe with the unassuming front and very friendly servers won me over with ease. The two young women behind the counter advised they were out if tasting spoons (ordinarily, you can taste before committing). However, they were helpful with descriptions.