Sandwich Theory

I love this place its my favorite to go and grab lunch from the staff is always very friendly and the place is always very clean. The food is AMAZING! Zero complaints.

This is my favorite sandwich shop in the universe! AND I had them cater a few birthday parties for my daughter - people were obsessed!

I wanted a breakfast sandwich without bread since I'm doing low carb, and they wanted to charge me a dollar more. I asked why and they said because it's on a plate. I was asking for no more food and was trying not to waste and throw out bread, and getting charged more for it. Shame on you! Poor customer service and I will never go back there.

The BEST SANDWICHES, etc. & CATERING IN TOWN
SUPER QUALITY,VALUE and SERVICE!!!!

Figured it was time to write a review since I've been a dedicated customer for over a year now, lol. I love love love LOVE the food offered by Sandwich Theory! Everything is always fresh and the variety of food they offer is great. My faves are their Blackened Chicken Salad and their Chicken Noodle Soup. Their oatmeal and salads are also amazing. The staff is super friendly and will help you out with any questions you have. I love that you can eat in as well and the environment is really great for a quick lunch or lunch date. My only complaints are the following and they aren't really complaints: they get VERY busy during your traditional 12 noon lunch hour so you can expect a small 10-15 min wait (which isn't bad honestly - they move fast) and they don't deliver for any order under $15 but that seems to be the trend in Montclair. Overall they have great food and great service which makes this one of the few places where prices feel fair. This is definitely a place to try when you're in the area.