Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant

Saw their menu on trip advisor. Went in the following day, this place was awesome. The owner Bob was really accommodating. I had the buffalo chicken salad, it was OUT OF THIS WORLD. DEF going back!!

Simply the Best Pizza in all of Long Island. Ordered their famous Buffalo Chicken pizza and no other place I have gone too compares! By far one of the best quality Italian Restaurants on Lonf Island! Definitely recommend it.

Came in because I love Italian food and I heard alot of good feedback about Plum Tomatoes. Had the chicken parm entree & a large cannoli. The cannoli is truly awesome, considering it had chocolate chips in the creme and I'm a chocolate fiend, so that was a huge plus. This would be a nice place to take someone for dinner. The chicken parm actually tasted better to me when I saved my lunch & had it reheated later on to finish it for dinner. Definitely will come back and a shout out to Bob who is the owner and a nice guy.

This service is horrible, I went in a couple of times around 12:00-12:30 and I understand there's a long wait but they're all over the place. The girl at the register is trying to handle paying customers and the phone and once and I presume the older guy is the manager and he just constantly scolds her. Constantly yelling and her and the staff when all I see him do is stay on the register like its a hard job. He rang me up all times and he over charges my card two dollars, I ended up paying 8.42 for two slices and a can of soda. Terrible, they just tossed in my slices like I wasn't watching and I had watched them drop a chicken roll and hide it somewhere instead of throwing it out. Outrageous!!! I will never return to an unsanitary dictator ran place again.

Great pizza place, but it loses a star for being inconsistent. Sometimes the quality if a plain pie is great from here, other times it suffers from either being undercooked and liquidy, or being overcooked and the edges are burnt. On the other hand, it's worth getting the 2 pizza deal that is only available with an online order (2 Large Pies, 12 Garlic Knots, 2-Liter Soda/$26). Great deal if you're looking to buy pizza as a group.