Pizza Haven

I love this place. The buffalo chicken slice is awesome and the garlic knots with cheese. You can't go wrong.

Awesome pizza, chicken rolls and garlic knots.
A+++

I would love to tell you how the food tastes but, unfortunately, I can't.

I ordered from them on seamless and received what I can only describe as one of the worst customer experiences I've ever had in a decade of living in NYC.

After an hour of not receiving my food, I called the restaurant and received what I can only describe as completely unacceptable behavior towards a customer.
Eventually I got to speak to Pete (the manager) who was very helpful and promised not only that I would receive my food in 5 minutes but that he would hand deliver my next order himself (something that I appreciated on his part).

The food never came. I called again, asked for Pete, no Pete. They then told me they were canceling my order and hung up on me. I attempted to call several more times which they screened until eventually reaching someone only for him to use profanity in telling me that he was not delivering my food.

I then had to contact seamless and spend over half an hour on the phone with a customer representative to receive the credit for my food and some compensation for the inconvenience. I ordered my food at 11:23 PM. Only managed to resolve the details with Seamless at 1:20AM. Everything in my neighborhood was closed by then so... no dinner for me.

Having been deployed to Afghanistan, I've met people who've shot at me that I like more than these guys. This is by far one of the worst experiences I've had with a restaurant ever.

I love Pizza Haven and have found them to be very accommodating in giving great customer service. The pizza is a throwback to the days pizza used to taste. I give them a big thumbs up!!!!!
You just can't please everyone all the time no matter how hard you try, someone will always have something bad to say. I have been going there for years and am in the customer service industry and know when I receive great service from an establishment!!!!!

Pizza is of the utmost importance to me and my motto for years was 2 slices a day. I might have to change that after discovering the joy of a Pizza Haven slice because the slices are a generous enough size that sometimes just 1 will fill my pizza quotient for the day.

I can't speak to the specialty slices or much else but when it comes to a plain slice that is reheated right it is extremely hard to beat Pizza Haven. The crust is crispy enough to stay steady in your hand (unlike Grandpa's pizza within the block which has sloppy floppy slices).

The parlor itself if pretty small but has 3 tables of 4 and a small 2-seater but locals will sit with each other at the tables as they stop in for a bite. The walls are adorned in good ole pizza parlor fashion with Coca-Cola ads and NYC sports teams and there is even a stand-up video game console in the dining section giving a cool nostalgic feel to the space.

The staff is usually great and a few of them love to talk sports while reheated your slices. If you get anything to go they wrap the pizza box like a package being sent across the country.