Most important part, the pie: Peach pie was lacking flavor and the crust was so hard I could barely cut into it.
Service: woman at the front was clearly swamped and had to ask for help from the woman in the back who was comically blase about taking orders or even engaging. Slightly passive aggressive as well. Would actually recommend people go just to experience that, felt very stereotypically Brooklyn.
Interior: Cute design, some nice elements, not setup well for flow of customers or those waiting to order. Open shelving and pies laying around make it appear a bit sloppy, but with some small improvements it could be really nice.