Evelyn's Kitchen

Great cookies and other sweets!

Amazing baked goods (the pudgies are phenomenal!) and the lunch and dinner is quite incredible too! East Harlem has few hidden gems, this is certainly one of them!!

Food is GREAT. customer service.. eeeeehhhh, not as good. The owner refused to allow delivery to my building which is just one block out of their delivery zone when going uptown even though going downtown, their range is MUCH farther than my building is. What's your issue with coming just 7 blocks north??

She even refused when I offered to meet the delivery guy right across the street which WAS in the delivery zone. Rules are rules but the delivery guy had no problem, it was supposedly the owner's call on this one.

So I ended up placing a whole new order online with a fake address and just met the guy. when you have a friend who's pregnant in the house and a craving hits, you just gotta make it happen. but I won't be giving evelyn's place any more of MY money. Even if the food was delicious. Bad service just leaves a nasty taste in my mouth.

I ordered the lemon garlic chicken sandwich and a nice little surprise come with it a free blondie (it was amazing btw). The lemon garlic chicken sandwich (minus the tomatoes I don't like tomatoes you may) was tasty. The chicken was tender and the sauce added a kick to it.

Imaginative, addictive, and (yes), extremely indulgent, not to mention SO yummy. Shipping is fast and convenient too! Try the blondies.