Best Pizza on 1st Avenue

Only tried plain, through and through NY pizza. Quick and friendly. Worth it.

Unquestionably the best pizza on first avenue.

NOT AT ALL the best pizza on first and the service we encountered was even worse! It was maybe 35-40 minutes before closing and the pizza toppings were all sliding off the pizza and the garlic knots were maybe luke warm, if that. Sad thing is I was located only 3 blocks away. Worst part of the experience with them was... when my husband got the door for the pizza and handed the man the money, the delivery man said "that's it?" regarding his tip, which was about 18% for a pizza guaranteed in 15-20 minutes and showed up after 20 minutes, and we were only 3 blocks away! I made my husband call the manager as that was MOST INAPPROPRIATE, and she was very kind and helpful. Hopefully she addressed her delivery guy! We will not be ordering from there ever again.

They are a little rude and be careful they will add and extra dollar and when you ask they tray to explain but the get confused to I just don't line to be robbery that all ,think about a dollar extra every people !!!

On the fence about this place. I finally find some white pizza in NY and it wasn't as good as I thought it should be. I'm used to heavy garlicky, oil goodness underneath the cheese with veggie toppings or none at all. The slice I had was mushroom and spinach, it was iust 'okay'. And to think I was going to order another slice with spinach and tomato, at $4 a slice, it wouldn't have been worth it. I guess my quest begins again for the perfect white pizza in NY.