Bantam Bagels

Staff was super nice and informed us on how to properly eat the food. Price was little steep for the size but it's New York so that's a given. It's worth trying but not something I love.

Delicious! Loved the birthday, jalapeño, and hangover ones! Great concept and love that they serve them warm. Would have given it 5 stars, but the employee was downright unpleasant. Almost makes me not want to come back...

After going past this place every single day for ages on my way to work, I finally decided to stop in today. First observation; these are really really expensive! I mean, I could go two blocks down and get an entire bagel with cream cheese for $1.50! Anyway, I was curious to try them. I ordered two dozen to bring to the office and share with some co-workers. The classic bagels are decent, nice and doughy and sufficiently stuffed with tasty cream cheese. French toast bagel was odd, good tasting bagel but the cream cheese tasted like just maple syrup and was very liquid. Went everywhere. Birthday cake was my favorite because it had this extremely sweet cream cheese inside. Wouldn't go out of my way for these, but they're decent and I'll stop back from time to time.

The best customer service! I contacted them about an online order that I needed the following day and they responded right away and made it happen even though they don't typically ship overnight on that particular day. Professional, understanding customer service staff which is hard to come by nowadays. Also, the bagels were delicious! A big hit at a brunch party I hosted.

This is the original store for Bantam Bagels. They specialize in stuffed bagel balls. The offerings range from sweet to savory, so that they can cover breakfast and all other meals or snacks of the day. I wouldn't really go out of my way for it, but I can see it being a destination for buying something unique for a party or picnic.

The shop itself is small, doesn't offer a restroom or any space (other than a two person counter and a bench outside) to really sit and enjoy your purchase.

We tried a variety of flavors and were not disappointed with any of them. I would certainly consider these unique items as perfect for a picnic.