I know this is unheard of but I found a HONEST car repair shop on Staten Island!
No, I'm NOT LYING!
An honest auto mechanic is a scarce commodity here on swinging Staten Island ... Angelo Leotta's Auto Repair is DEFINITELY one and I will go back to them ... I had a catalytic converter that needed replacing and the local Honda dealer wanted $1800, so instead I got it done here at Leotta's for $650 using Honda parts ... I've bought other cars to them in the past and found they fix the problem right the first time and make no unnecessary repairs.
I can't say enough nice things about this place!