One block from the Times Square you will find Abitino's Pizza. It was a really nice surprise because we were exhausted and then we found this place. We sat there and was one of the best NY's pizza I ever ate so far.
They have also some other pastas and some meat balls, but the pizza is wht moves it and it is really good. There is another places in NY that serves Pizza, but definitely Albitino's is the best one.
This is not a huge place, this is small ans sometimes you have to wait for a table, but totally worth it.